Welcome to Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville
Muscarella's Pizza on Main St. in Williamsville is a beloved gem in the Buffalo pizza scene, known for its exceptional flavors and unique offerings. Locals rave about the crispy, square-cut pies that highlight the delicious crust, ideal for dipping. The signature garlic crust and perfectly charred pepperoni elevate the traditional pizza experience. Complementing the pizza, their wings are also a crowd favorite, attracting fans of all ages. With its dedication to quality and value, Muscarella’s stands out, making it a must-try destination for pizza enthusiasts in Western New York. Experience the taste that keeps customers coming back for nearly two decades!
Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville: Reviews & Ratings
Been getting muscarellas for almost 20 yrs now. Love their crust! One of the few that cut their circle pies into squares so you get 4 "corners" with a lot of crust. Great for dipping into additional sauce or enjoying the delicious taste and crunch with a little of the pizza on it for flavor. You get the crustless pieces in the middle . Pepperoni perfectly chared. It's my top 3 pizza place in buffalo.
This is legit the best pizza I’ve ever had. The cup pepperoni was cooked perfectly. The garlic crust on the pizza is AMAZING. Honey mustard & Italian wings are also excellent. All the food got delivered still hot. I’ll definitely be back.
Have had a lot of pizza’s from all over the Buffalo area this is one of my favorites. Great pizza and wings highly recommend!
Was really surprised by how good the pizza and wings were. We are normally a fan of Picasso's and I am not from Buffalo New York I grew up about an hour and a half outside of Buffalo. I moved to the Buffalo area like five or six years ago and have tried a lot of pizza places around here. Muscarellas is up there in like top five. Also it was 20 cheaper to get pizza and wings here then it would have been to get it from Picasso's you can't go wrong with that.
Best Buffalo style Pizza in WNY! Hands down! I have had tons of Buffalo pizza and this place is my favorite. It has the most flavor in a pizza. I also love the crispy pepperonis. It’s a hidden gem of a place and a must try! This place is my favorite and Picasso’s is my second. All other Buffalo pizza is tied for third.
Our favorite local shop. Not much seating for dining in, but that doesn't bother us since we always pick up. Great all around Buffalo pizza, and seriously, try the garlic/parm crust!
First time trying this place.... and so happy I did!! The pizza was full of toppings and the wings were still crispy after the drive home(40 minutes). Definitely a place I will order from again. Thank you for a wonderful experience.
First time trying this place. Ordered online. Picked up no issue. Open the box and I laugh and shake my head everytime I see this. Square box. Circle shaped pizza cut in squares. IMO only pizza to be cut in squares should be sheets. Despite the un preferable cutting style this pizza was delicious. Great cook. Amazing cup n char. Perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. Crust was great. This was a fantastic pizza. Thank you
Location
-
5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221, United States Hotline: +1 716-204-9020
Welcome to Muscarella's Pizza, an essential spot for pizza lovers in Williamsville, New York, located conveniently at 5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221. With nearly two decades of serving the community, Muscarella's has etched its name into the hearts—and stomachs—of locals like Jason Sinsabaugh, who praises its unique square-cut pizza that tantalizes with 'four corners' of crust, perfect for dipping. The craftsmanship of their pizzas is evident in every slice, distinguished by a gorgeous, crispy crust that retains a delightful crunch.
The star of the show is undoubtedly the pepperoni, which receives rave reviews for its impeccable char and flavor. Customers can't help but emphasize their love for the garlic crust, which elevates the experience to new heights. Lo Rivera, another satisfied patron, claims it’s the best pizza he’s ever had, complemented perfectly by their honey mustard and Italian wings. Every dish at Muscarella's exemplifies quality and consistency, always served piping hot.
But it’s not just about the pizza; the wings are also a noteworthy mention. As Heather Winiarz discovered, they stand shoulder-to-shoulder with some of the area's more established pizzerias, providing an affordable yet delicious feast. Kimberly O'Meara is a staunch advocate for Muscarella's, declaring it the best Buffalo-style pizza in Western New York, a statement that will undoubtedly resonate with many. Muscarella’s Pizza- Main St. Williamsville promises more than just a meal; it delivers a slice of Buffalo culture grounded in flavor, tradition, and community.
If you find yourself seeking a pizza experience that captures the essence of Buffalo’s unique style, look no further than Muscarella's. Call +1 716-204-9020 to place your order or stop by to savor what many consider the pinnacle of pizza perfection in Williamsville.