Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville Menu
Welcome to the delightful world of Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville, where pizza perfection thrives. Located at 5526 Main St, this gem captures the essence of Buffalo-style pizza like no other. The menu boasts a variety of offerings, but its signature feature is undoubtedly the unique square-cut pizzas that enhance every pizza experience. Each slice delivers a satisfying crunch, perfect for dipping or savoring solo.
- Crispy pepperoni: A crowd favorite, perfectly charred for that smoky flavor.
- Garlic-infused crust: A taste sensation that elevates the pizza's profile.
- Affordable combo deals: Quality pizza and wings at prices that keep customers coming back.
With a devoted following for nearly two decades, Muscarella's is cherished not just for its outstanding flavors but also for its welcoming atmosphere. Each bite reinforces its reputation—making it a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic Buffalo pizza.
WRAPS
GRILLED STEAK
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
GRILLED STEAK CAESAR
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
GRILLED CHICKEN
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
SUPREME CHICKEN OR STEAK
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
TURKEY
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
ASSORTED
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
TUNA
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
VEGETARIAN
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
HAM
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
ANTIPASTO
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
CHICKEN FINGER
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, onions on request, mayo or oil. Choice between Wheat or White Flour Wraps
STEAK PARM
Each sub comes with sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
EGGPLANT
Each sub comes with sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
MEATBALL
Each sub comes with sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
CHICKEN FINGER
Each sub comes with sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
ITALIAN SAUSAGE
Each sub comes with sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
PARM SUBS
SUBMARINES
ASSORTED
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
B.L.T.
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
BACON CHEESEBURGER
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
CAPICOLA (Bison)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
CHEESE (Baked)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
CHEESEBURGER
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
CHICKEN CORDON BLEU
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls. Sahlen's ham, chicken fingers & Swiss cheese
CHICKEN FINGER
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
GRILLED CHICKEN
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
GRILLED CHICKEN SUPREME
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls. Sweet Peppers & onions or HP & onions
HAM (Sahlen's)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
HAMBURGER
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
ITALIAN SAUSAGE PATTY
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
MUSCARELLA MELT
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls. Melted cheddar, BBQ chicken fingers, bacon, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes
ROYAL (Sausage & Capicola)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
SALAMI (Hard)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
STEAK (Chopped Sirloin)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
STEAK SUPREME
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls. Sweet Peppers & onions or HP & onions
STEAK & SAUSAGE
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
STINGER
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls. Lettuce & tomatoes on request choice of condiments, includes chopped sirloin steak, chicken fingers and your choice of flavor and bacon.
TUNA
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
TURKEY (Latinas #1 Choice)
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
TURKEY BACON CLUB
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
VEGETARIAN
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls. Includes black olives, green olives, hot peppers and cheese on request
VINCENZO Special Assorted cold cuts & Italian sausage
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
SICILIAN PIZZA SUB
All subs include lettuce, tomato & cheese. Your of choice condiments. Onions on request. Choice of White or Wheat Costanzo Rolls
2 Slices Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
Add 2.00 for Drink.
6 Boneless Wings French Fries
Add 2.00 for Drink.
3 Chicken Fingers French Fries
Add 2.00 for Drink.
LUNCH SPECIALS
DAILY SPECIALS
Small Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 10 Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Large Pizza (C1 Topping) & 10 Chicken Fingers
Any style wing sauce included
Large Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 20 Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Colossal Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 30 Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Sheet Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 50 Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Small Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 10 Boneless Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Large Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 20 Boneless Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Colossal Pizza (C1 Topping) & 30 Boneless Wings
Any style wing sauce included
Sheet Pizza (C 1 Topping) & 50 Boneless Wings
Any style wing sauce included
BONELESS WINGS SPECIALS
PIZZA
COLOSSAL PIZZA 20" CHEESE
Garlic Parmesan Honey Sesame • Hot Honey • Hot Honey and Garlic - 1.75 Extra
SHEET 24/32 SQ. CHEESE
Garlic Parmesan Honey Sesame • Hot Honey • Hot Honey and Garlic - 1.75 Extra
LARGE 16" PIZZA CHEESE
Garlic Parmesan Honey Sesame • Hot Honey • Hot Honey and Garlic - 1.75 Extra
SMALL 12" PIZZA CHEESE
Garlic Parmesan Honey Sesame • Hot Honey • Hot Honey and Garlic - 1.75 Extra
PERSONAL 9" PIZZA CHEESE
Garlic Parmesan Honey Sesame • Hot Honey • Hot Honey and Garlic - 1.75 Extra
SLICE OF CHEESE & PEPPERONI
*Pizzas are well done *Light baked is available upon request
CHICKEN FINGER PIZZA
No Splitting Pizzas
BROCCOLI & CHEDDAR PIZZA
No Splitting Pizzas. Olive oil, 2 Cheeses & broccoli florets
STEAK PIZZA
No Splitting Pizzas. Made either red (with sauce) or white (with oil & garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot or sweet peppers
SICILIAN PIZZA
No Splitting Pizzas. Made with 100% olive oil, fresh tomatoes, onions, Asiago cheese & spices. Anchovies on request
THE WORKS
No Splitting Pizzas. Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives
THE "HOG"
No Splitting Pizzas. Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage & ham
THE ROMANO
No Splitting Pizzas. Includes Romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers
SPECIALTY PIZZA
CALZONES
CREATE YOUR OWN
Includes cheese Each Item added 3.00 upcharge
SPECIALTY PIZZA CALZONE
ANTIPASTO
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00 Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, capicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni
JULIENNE
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00 Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, turkey, ham & provolone cheese
TUNA
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00 Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese
GRILLED CHICKEN
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00 Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone
CAESAR SALAD
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00
GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00
CHEFS
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00 Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese
CHICKEN FINGER SALAD
Sm: 1 dressing Lg: 2 dressings Extra Dressing 1.00 Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & cheddar
SALADS
SIDE ORDERS
FRANKIE FRIES
Grilled Steak/Cheese, Bleu Cheese, Mild, Medium, Bbq Or Hot Sauce, Chicken Fingers, Spinach, Onions, Tomatoes and Mozzarella Cheese
FRIED DOUGH BALLS
LOADED GARLIC BREAD
2 Cheeses, (Lettuce & Tomato Optional)
FRENCH FRIES
MOZZARELLASTICKS
Includes Marinara Sauce
BBQ FRENCH FRIES
Includes bleu cheese
PIZZA LOGS
Includes Marinara Sauce
LOADED FRIES
Includes bacon and cheddar
CAJUN ONION RINGS
LOADED WAFFLE FF
Includes bleu cheese
SWEET POTATO FRIES W/HONEY
CAJUN FRENCH FRIES
Includes bleu cheese
GARLIC BREAD
NO CHEESE
WAFFLE FRIES
ONION RINGS
GARLIC BREAD W/CHEESE
FRIED CAULIFLOWER
Includes bleu cheese
GARLIC BREAD W/ CHEESE & TOMATO
FRIED MUSHROOMS
Includes bleu cheese
BREADSTICKS
FRIED ZUCCHINI
Includes Marinara Sauce
BREADSTICKS WITH CHEESE
JALAPENO POPPERS
Includes bleu cheese
TATOR TOTS
LOADED TATOR TOTS
20 OZ
We serve Coca-Cola Products: Cherry Coke Coke Diet Coke Sprite Logan Berry. Dasani Orange Root Beer Ginger Ale Lemonade Pink Lemonade
2 LITER
We serve Coca-Cola Products: Cherry Coke Coke Diet Coke Sprite Logan Berry. Dasani Orange Root Beer Ginger Ale Lemonade Pink Lemonade
WATER
We serve Coca-Cola Products: Cherry Coke Coke Diet Coke Sprite Logan Berry. Dasani Orange Root Beer Ginger Ale Lemonade Pink Lemonade